Sunday, March 18, 2012

Fourth Sunday of Lent

Galatians 4:22-31 / John 6:1-15

Saint Paul presents us today with a very subtle and, if not read carefully, worrisome claim. In his letter to the Galatians, Paul sets before us Abraham and his two sons, not here both named, but he has in mind Ishmael, the elder who was born of the slave girl Hagar, and Isaac, the younger, born of Abraham's wife Sarah as a result of God's promise. Paul warns us that these things are said by an allegory. That is, Paul is not claiming that the stories in Genesis of Abraham, Sarah, Hagar, Isaac, and Ishmael are not historically true. Rather, he wants us to see that while he seems to be speaking of these figures in the past, he is actually aiming to speak about something else, that is allegorein, to speak otherwise.

Why does Paul give this warning? It turns out that the reading he provides yields some surprising tension with the Scriptures themselves. His first claim, that Ishmael is born of a slave woman and so of the flesh, Isaac of a free woman and so of the spirit would quite easily have been received by a surface and facile reading of Genesis, one which held up the people of God's promise over the pretenses of their Gentile neighbors. Then, however, things get tricky. Paul associates the son of Hagar, the son of a slave, with the giving of the Law on Sinai, with the very gracious act by which God established the sons of Isaac as a priestly people, a holy nation. Moreover, Sinai itself, and then by transference Jerusalem, are shifted to Arabia, to the land of Ishmael's exile and the place of the nations who do not know God. In contrast, the Church, and here one must have in mind the gathering of the Gentiles into Christ as well as the Jews, turns out to be Jerusalem, and these sons of darkness who grew up in pagan cult, turn out to be the sons of the free woman, the children of promise.

Now, on a facile reading, Paul has simply taken the Jewish disdain for the Gentile people and inverted it, claiming that God does not favor the Jews, but favors instead his (Gentile) Church. Yet, that reading is dangerously mistaken. The question here is not whether God loves the people of promise, nor is it whether the Law is good an righteous. The issue Paul is putting before us is rather the question of human presumption and divine initiative.

In the case of Abraham and Sarah, God had promised them descendants countless as the stars. However, anxious and not trusting fully in God, they sought together to force God's hand by producing a child on their own initiative, through Abraham's begetting Ishmael by Hagar. Ishmael himself is not without God's promises, being destined to father a great nation himself and being, with his mother, watched over in the wilderness when Abraham and Sarah cruelly cast them out with a glib assertion that God had promised to make of him a great nation and so he need not fear sending them to their death in the desert. Even so, he is not the child of God's promise to Abraham. This promise is fulfilled in Isaac, conceived by God's omnipotence, despite the unbelieving laughter of Sarah or the weakness of Abraham, who himself must confront that weakness and trust in God when asked to destroy in sacrifice that very answer to his prayed by slaying his own son.

What Paul wants us to see is that the formation of God's holy people, the gathering of the elect, has always been and will always be the result not of our own plans and initiative, but the result of God's work in us, God's fidelity to his own promises. Our attempts to force his hand, to produce the effect which God reserves to himself, will inevitably end in sadness, in a pale imitation of the promise, even as the Ishmaelites would never be, and could never be, the people God had chosen as his own. So, for Paul, the spiritual danger of the Jewish people facing the newborn Church was in living as though they were themselves the masters and arbiters of their own election by God. In cleaving to the Law as a way to distinguish themselves from the Gentiles, and so act as though God could not ever choose them as well, they had ironically made themselves to be like Ishmael, the product of an attempt to bypass and take control of God's promise.

The worry for us in Christ, then, ought to be clear. We can and should rejoice in the marvelous redemption won for us in the blood of Christ, and in him we need not expect any further revelation. Even so, we can be just as guilty of attempting to force God's hand, of determining on our initiative where, when, how, and to whom God's grace of election will come. The mercy extended to us in Jesus Christ is meant always to disturb any such security, that we might find our foundation in no one but him, in no other promise but his, and in no other way to fulfill that promise save by his gracious work. This is the freedom wherewith Christ has made us free, and it is the freedom which our Lenten way opens to all who are called from the slavery of self-assertion to the liberty of receiving our truest selves from the Lord Jesus Christ.

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Saturday of the Third Week in Lent

Daniel 13:1-9, 15-17, 19-30, 33-62 / John 8:1-11

Why is it so hard for many simply to condemn the iniquity of the abuse of women? Why is it that, when some highlight how it is that women are the subject of their husbands', or their partners', or even their clients' abuse and cruelty, the Church, not merely in her ministers but even more so in the laity, is so awkward in denouncing the fact as a grace injustice and a moral evil? It is as though we want to decry how the abuse of women is horrendous and yet we feel compelled to add, "Of course it is, but yet ..." That is, we feel inclined to assert that not only are women the victim of spousal abuse, or that "while it is true that the abuse of women is an unspeakable crime, yet we ought not to conclude ..." and then add some addendum we fear will be forgotten or overlooked if we should, without hesitation, condemn the abuse of women tout court.

In the Gospel, Jesus does not determine the moral "worthiness" of the woman caught in adultery before defending her from the wrath of the crowd. Indeed, as we hear from her accusers, she is indeed guilty of adultery. All the same, Jesus' challenge remains: He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her. This challenge is not premised at all upon parsing out the moral state of the woman, who, as we learn, is in fact guilty of the crime of which she has been accused. Rather, altogether apart from the question of her guilt, Jesus puts before her accusers, those who would make her die the terrible death of stoning, the altogether righteous but impossible standard, namely, that to lay a hand upon her, to do this woman a single bit of harm, calls for absolute purity on the part of the executioner of judgment. The prophet Daniel, while convinced rightly of the innocence of Susanna, is less bothered of proving her innocence as he is of ferreting out the judges' guilt. Their fault is found not in defending the honor of Susanna, but in showing that the judges are themselves false, themselves deserving of death.

In the Church, we must name the cruelty and violence we face, the daily violence faced by women, Christian women, women married sacramentally in holy Mother Church. The problem is so clear, so unavoidable, that one wonders why we do not hear more about it. Why is it that women feel themselves better served by turning to lesbian activists in state-sponsored crisis clinics than they do from their own pastors, much less their sisters in the faith? Why is it that the Church must explain and defend her stance on behalf of women, rather than having the same be so obvious as to be in no need of explanation or defense?

The woman caught in adultery received, without her even asking it, the unconditional pardon from the Lord: Hath no man condemned thee, woman? No man, Lord. Neither will I condemn thee. Are we prepared to defend women as fiercely, as courageously, and as generously? Are we prepared, without any question as to moral guilt, to stand up on behalf of those women who have been abused by the men to whom they have, wisely or not, entrusted their lives, and to drive away those who would condemn them for their sins? Can we yet speak with Jesus, and finally understand his words, having made them our own: Neither will I condemn thee?

Friday, March 16, 2012

Friday of the Third Week in Lent

Numbers 20:1-3, 6-13 / John 4:5-42

For many of us, being rightly understood is a bit of a challenge. We can find ourselves drawn into arguments, often quite fierce and bitter ones, trying to make sure that the other party truly sees what we see and how we see it. Again and again our interlocutor's responses suggest that she does not indeed get what we mean, and so we press on, and harder, our frustration mounting as she continues holding her own view. We are convinced that, should she truly see things as we see them, she would abandon her error and happily embrace the truth we have come to know.

When faced with this kind of misunderstanding, we are likely to do one of two things. We might grow angry, our arguments fiercer, and the concern for the person sitting across from us becoming all the less, the victory of our truth being our sole concern. Or, we are tempted to regard either the person with whom we are speaking or the truth we want to share as of no account. Not wanting to live with our failure to bring about mutual appreciation of the truth we have seen and known, we resolve our frustration in a false way, pretending we do not care one way or the other.

In Jesus' meeting of the Samaritan woman at the well, we see quite a different model. It is certainly the case that the woman remains for quite some time in shades of error, grasping bits of truth about Jesus, but often mixed with other commitments to her people's traditions or the shame of her own problematic past and present with men. Yet, throughout it all, Jesus does not become frustrated or alarmed. He is not worried at her misunderstanding in the slightest. At the same time, Jesus is clearly committed to drawing this woman from error to truth, from unbelief to faith, from adoring what she does not know to adoring the Lord known by the Jews, and from that to the deeper goal, that she might adore the Father in spirit and in truth.

What we often forget as we present the Gospel to others is that it is Christ himself who is the best teacher, Christ himself who can lead others skillfully and patiently through their misapprehensions to his glorious truth. This is not to say that we, whether ordained ministers of the Good News of Jesus Christ or simply one of the baptized living out his vocation, do not have a role in proclaiming the Gospel, in making Jesus Christ known to our neighbor. Even so, it is not our skillful words of persuasion which will, in the end, remove the resistance of unbelief. It is, rather, the experience of Jesus Christ himself by the power of the Spirit that is the best, and indeed only, path to receive the new life of the Gospel. We can communicate to others what brought us to receive the truth of Jesus Christ, even as the woman did to her fellow Samaritans: He told me all things whatsoever I have done. Yet, in the end, it was not her testimony that brought the Samaritans to saving faith any more than it will be our convincing words.

Our hope, our joy, is that our words should direct others to attend to Christ, not that we could succeed in producing the gift of faith itself. May we long and rejoice to hear, as the Samaritan woman heard, that our arguments are no longer necessary, and that those who once did not believe can turn to us and say, We now believe, not for thy saying: for we ourselves have heard Him, and know that this is indeed the Savior of the world.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Thursday of the Third Week in Lent

Jeremiah 7:1-7 / Luke 4:38-44

There are those today who are disheartened by those brothers and sisters in the Catholic faith who have departed from the sacramental life of the Church and her worship, and may even have begun to drift away from the faith itself. For them, the point is clear. If one asserts that Jesus Christ is Lord, if one claims to hold to the Catholic faith, then no amount of disappointment in the behavior of her members or tepidness in her pastors can justify walking away. If Jesus Christ is Lord, the argument goes, then he is in his Church.

Others are disheartened by the Church herself, seeing either with sadness or with cynicism the failure of the Christian people to uphold in a clear and unambiguous way the dignity of all human persons. For them, the support of professed Catholics for the destruction of unborn life, for unreasoned refusal to attend to the scientific study of global climate change, for the removal of those public means of feeding the poor and caring for the abused, especially of children, for initiating and sustaining armed conflict between nations, and much more unsays whatever these same Christians assert in the proclamation of the Gospel. If Jesus Christ is Lord, so the argument goes, then he could not possibly be present in the Church.

To all of these, the Church puts before us the words of the prophet Jeremiah. Jeremiah was faced with a difficult work as a prophet, namely, to call the people of Judah back to fidelity and trust in God, to affirm them that God was with them and would defend them, while at the same time warning them against vain presumption, against presuming that the Lord is necessarily in his Temple, and thus one need not worry about the righteousness which the Lord demands in his Law, the righteousness which was the proper and necessary foundation for the Lord's choosing to dwell with his people. To abandon God because his people had strayed from their ways would be foolish, but so, too, would it be folly to presume that God would remain in his Temple even when his people had failed to uphold justice in settling disputed between neighbors, had oppressed the foreigner, the orphan, and the widow, had shed innocent blood, and had departed from the worship of the true God.

To leave the Church, to follow strange gods is, as Jeremiah warns us, only to our own hurt. Yet, to remain within the Church is to affirm social justice, to uphold right relationship with our neighbor, to show special concern, justice, and support for the weak, defenseless, and disadvantaged, to defend and protect the innocent and all those who are targets of violence and hatred for whatever reason or cause. There is no right worship, no giving proper adoration to the Lord Jesus Christ where there is no active, positive, material defense and promotion of the good of our neighbor, and most especially the good of the poor. God may not leave his Temple, of course, as it is nothing other than his own Body of which he is the Head. We, however, may well cut ourselves off from that same body through our hardness of heart to our brothers and sisters, even while all the while speaking pious words.

The Lord is the hope of his people, and his wills his Church to be the effective sign of that love and that justice for all the world to see. This is the goal of our Lenten fasting, our Lenten prayer, and our Lenten almsgiving, to be more and more like our Lord, of whom the Psalmist said: The eyes of all hope in Thee, O Lord; and Thou givest them meat in due season. Thou openest Thy hand, and fillest every living creature with blessing.

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Wednesday of the Third Week in Lent

Exodus 20:12-24 / Matthew 15:1-20

What kind of a motivator is fear? We tend to think it is not a very good one. Surely, we think, we ought to avoid what is to be avoided not out of anxiety, much less out of abject terror, but rather out of understanding. Fear, we think, is unhelpful precisely in being an enemy to understanding, opposed to the collective, contemplative stance that allows us to appreciate everything for what it is.

So, we at first glance think that Moses has it right when the people of Israel shy away from Sinai when they saw the voices, and the flames, and the sound of the trumpet, and the mount smoking. Seeing them being terrified and struck with fear, Moses says what Jesus would later say to his disciples, and what everyone says at one time or another to his beloved: Fear not. Yet, this is just when things take an unusual twist. Having just told them not to fear, Moses tells the people that God has come to try them, to prove them. And for what end? That the dread of Him might be in you, and you should not sin.

Now, what kind of prophet tells us not to fear precisely in order that we might have dread? What logic is there in that?

The answer lies in a distinction drawn in classic moral theology between servile fear and filial fear. Servile fear is a fear derived from the anticipated punishment or injury which will arise from offending another. It is rooted, that is, not in a concern for the other or for the wrongness that has caused the offense, but only in one's own integrity, and the threat that punishment will bring. In itself, servile fear in contrary to love.

In contrast, filial fear is the fear that arises from the injury another suffers because one's own acts have offended him. That is, in filial fear, one recognizes his own moral weakness, and is concerned that his own failings and failures will cause harm to another, especially to those whom he most loves. Filial fear, then, is not self-oriented like servile fear, but instead it arises from is is compatible with love. Indeed, the more one loves, the more one experiences filial fear, which leads not to paralysis, but to a renewed effort to moral goodness, to live a life worthy of the respect of the object of one's love.

This is why, on the one hand, the people of Israel needed to cease their fear, i.e. servile fear of destruction at the hand of God, and instead be filled with dread, in this case filial fear, which would lead them not to want to offend God by their sins. Jesus likewise critiques the scribes and Pharisees  in the Gospel not for their wanting to uphold the Law, nor even precisely for their living out the Law in light of human customs which they have girt about it. Rather, what concerns Jesus is that these customs have deadened them to a holy sense of dread of offending God through a failure to live righteously, as seen in their ways of avoiding the command to honor father and mother. Instead, Jesus sees in these customs a kind of servile fear, an anxiety about violating taboo, and not the wholesome fear that comes from a deeper love of God and of those whom God loves.

Jesus Christ, then, came both to remove our fear and to fill us with fear. Do we, in the times we have stumbled from our Lenten resolutions, find ourselves overcome with anxiety about how God treat us at the judgment, or have we embraced rather a better fear, the fear that our stumbling has revealed in us a tepid affection for our merciful Savior? If the latter, can we rekindle that fear not be trying to be more afraid, but rather by seeking all the more to love?

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Tuesday of the Third Week in Lent

4 Kings 4:1-7 / Matthew 18:15-22

And if he will not hear the church: let him be to thee as the heathen and publican.

There is a dangerous trope much in circulation these days. It asserts, rightly enough, that the Church is not simply the hierarchy. As Bl. John Henry Newman said, when asked about the role of the laity in the Church, "The Church would look rather silly without them!" So far, so good. Yet, the trope does not delay here. Typically the refrain is to say that the Church is not the hierarchy, but the people, by which is usually meant the laity and the (lower) clergy in sympathy with them. That is, the premise is that the Church is fundamentally divided, that the "real" weight of the Church is found in the people, and that the speaker claims to know what those people really want. More than that, this move is generally made to assert freedom from something clearly, even definitively, taught by the Church, as though to say that the Church, being the "people" rather than the hierarchy, our duty to uphold to Church turns out, perversely, to require rejection of the authoritative teaching of her ministers. Taking their cue from Matthew's Gospel, they claim that it is the bishops who will not hear the church, and so it is the bishops who are to be shunned and ignored, treated as the heathen and publican.

To be sure, the hierarchy has no guarantee of impeccability. The grace of office does not always extend to social graces, intellectual acuity, or, sadly, even basic human relating. Taken as individuals, while the teaching of a given bishop is to be received with docility, there is no guarantee even here that he will, simply by himself, rightly pass on the apostolic faith, much less that he will always rightly discern the proper application of that teaching to controverted questions of the day. In these matters, should what the bishop say or do trouble us, we are enjoined by Christ himself to rebuke him, and if he will not hear us in private, then before a few members of the Church, and if not even then, we have recourse only the the public word of the Church herself.

Yet, to presume that the court of public opinion, the sort of thing discovered by demographic studies and opinion polls, is the best barometer of the mens Ecclesiæ, the mind of the Church, is to exchange theology for sociology. The Church has no voice, no authentic voice properly her own, that is not a speaking of the faith of Christ, delivered once for all to the saints, sustained by the work of the Holy Spirit. It is always and only the voice of the one Body with Christ as the Head, and thus is it the voice not of percentages and shifting attitudes, but the voice of a structured and priestly people. That is, the voice of the Church is to be heard precisely where Christ willed it to be heard, which is to say, as articulated by the apostles and their successors as legitimate and authentic transmitters of the faith revealed in Christ.

This is why we cannot try to take refuge in pollsters numbers when what is to us certain and approved by God falls under the clear and unmistakable censure of the Church as voiced by her bishops in union across the world. To do so would be to mistake what Jesus wants us to hear about the authority of the Church. That authority is not the "authority of the people" any more than the body is merely he hierarchy without the laity. Rather, the authority of the Church is Christ's own authority as God and as risen Lord of all. It is his voice, as sustained by the Spirit in the faithful witness of the Scriptures and its authentic teaching by the clergy, along with its being lived out by the baptized in communion with one another. When we find our lives and our loves rebuked by the clear words of the Gospel as proclaimed by the Church's ministers, do we have the humility to receive it, and receiving it, be gained back once again as brothers and sisters in Christ?

Monday, March 12, 2012

Monday of the Third Week in Lent

4 Kings 5:1-15 / Luke 4:23-30


Why hast thou rent thy garments? Let him come to me, and let him know that there is a prophet in Israel.


When Naaman the Syrian, the general of the king of Syria and a man not to be trifled with, came to the king of Israel to seek healing for his leprosy, the king was none too pleased. Indeed, more to the point, he was frightened and thrown into a panic. For the king of Israel, his arrival could only be read as a challenge, a set-up to provide the pretence for war. Am I God, the king asks, to be able to kill and give life, that this man hath sent to me to heal a man of his leprosy? Mark, and see how he seeketh occasions against me.

Now, the king of Israel knew perfectly well the stories told of the mighty works which God performed at the time of the patriarchs, of Moses, and of the judges. He even knew of the more recent mighty deeds that had been accomplished by the prophet Elijah. Yet, despite knowing all of this, the king could not imagine that right then and there, right in his very midst, God would do anything wonderful. He interprets Naaman's request on a purely earthly level because, whatever he may tell himself he believes, in actual fact he lives and thinks as though his only hope is in this world. That the absence of regular wonders accomplished by God might not be a sign of divine incapacity, but of the freedom of the Lord to choose when, where, and how to act in the world, whether by sustaining the ordinary course of things or by dramatic restoration of what has been lost, never occurred to him.

We confess great and wonderful things, not only the mighty deeds God did of old for the patriarchs, judges, kings, and prophets, but even more so what God has accomplished in the Incarnation of his only-begotten Son, Jesus Christ. We proclaim to the world his power over unclean spirits, his healing touch which could give sight to the blind and make the dead to be alive again, his profound insight into the human heart and making known what we imagine remains forever hidden. We know all of his, or at least we profess to do so. Even so, when presented with a challenge, whether posed by an unbeliever or by our fellow believers, like the king of Israel we tend to balk. Whatever we may tell ourselves about what we believe, we are sorely tempted to act and think as though our only hope is in our own power.

While it is not acceptable to demand of Jesus Christ signs at our bidding, to satisfy our doubts or he doubts of an unbelieving world, if is our task and glory as believers to bear witness to the world and to ourselves of the mighty deeds God is working here and now. That God works in simple ways, in ways not open to consumption by the global news outlets, does not make his activity any less worthy of our confidence. Unlike Naaman, we need not turn our noses up to the simple but powerful means we have been given in Jesus Christ: the sacraments, intercessory prayer, mercy and the forgiveness of sins. These can and do work wonders, even proper miracles

The world is afflicted no less than Naaman was, and in Jesus Christ we have something greater by far than the prophet Elisha. Do we have the confidence to trust in him, and to draw any who are seeking an answer to their needs the only source that will satisfy?