Sunday, March 11, 2012

Third Sunday in Lent

Ephesians 5:1-9 / Luke 11:14-28

In The Two Towers, the second novel in J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings trilogy, the hobbits Merry and Pippin, having fled from the orcs that had captured them, escape into ancient Fangorn Forest, and there encounter Treebeard the Ent, one of a race of tree-men awakened ages ago by the elves and given the power of speech. Merry and Pippin see the goodness in Treebeard's heart and hope to convince him, and through him his fellow Ents, to join in their struggle against the rising darkness that threatens to corrupt and destroy all that is good in Middle Earth. To the hobbits, the question is clear. While at an earlier time they might have seen such affairs as well beyond the concerns of simply people like themselves, they now know that there is no third position, no neutral stance in the struggle they face. One is either on the side of the Free Peoples or is aiding and abetting their fall. One is either on the side of the Dark Lord, or struggling to resist him.

Treebeard the Ent is less convinced. He regards wars as the affair of Men, Elves, and Wizards. Yet, why does he see things this way? Why does he not at least sympathize with those who are fighting for the right? As Treebeard tells the hobbits sagely and not without regret: I am not altogether on anybody's side, because nobody is altogether on my side, if you understand me. For the Ent, as often for us, most, if not all, struggles that come before us do not admit to an easy resolution between the party in the right and the party in the wrong. We have our own dreams, our own personal projects, our own way of envisioning what is right and just, and rarely does any side in a conflict embody most, or even much, of what we hold dear. We find it hard to commit ourselves wholly to a project that undermines and compromises our integrity as the price for advancing the cause of other things we hold dear.

So, the words of Jesus Christ may well strike us as difficult to hear: He that is not with Me is against Me: and he that gathereth not with Me scattereth. Can anything so complicated as the living out of human life be reduced to so simple an equation? Do we not rather hold that there is greater wisdom is marking out nuance, in seeing not black or white, not this or that, but rather many shades of gray, many truths and many paths, a harmony across diversity rather than a binary and irrevocable separation of the right and the wrong?

There is a deep truth to Treebeard's lament that nobody is altogether on our side, but there is a deeper way in which Treebeard, and we, are mistaken. There is in fact one who is altogether on our side, namely our Lord and God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. More than that, it is God, and God alone, who is altogether on our side. The irony and tragedy of sin is not merely that we become enemies of our neighbor and enemies of God, but that, in becoming enemies of God, who is the very source of our being and our integrity, the very good we seek in every choosing, the truth we perceive in every thought, we become enemies of ourselves. Sadly, then, we ourselves must be counted among those who are not on our own side.

It is precisely because we are not, so long as we are broken by sin, entirely on our own side that we will necessarily be scattered unless we side with Jesus Christ. It is only through Jesus Christ, who alone is altogether for us in a way that not even we are for ourselves, that we can have restored to us the very selves we thought we meant to defend and protect. Our loves, our desires, our personal projects, our imagined self-authenticity: none of these are or can be true except insofar as they are the real truth about ourselves, namely, that about us which Jesus Christ aims to bring to fruition. Apart from Jesus, we are necessarily and unavoidably, a kingdom divided against itself. With him, we need not fear that within us that still lives in rebellion, for we can take confidence in the stronger man, Jesus Christ, who will despoil our own rebellious self, and bring us, at once both captive and set free, into his own divine and glorious life.

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Saturday of the Second Week in Lent

Genesis 27:6-40 / Luke 15:11-32

In the fairy tale Sleeping Beauty, the heroine receives a series of blessings from the fairy godmothers who have been invited to her christening. However, a wicked fairy, angry at not having been invited and in no mood for charity, comes to the christening and, in place of a blessing, curses the infant, fating her to die upon her coming of age when she pierces her hand with a spindle. The one good fairy remaining, who had not yet given her blessing, despite the parents' entreaties, cannot simply undo what has been said. Beauty is doomed to a terrible fate by means of a spindle when she comes of age. However, her word has power as well, and she is able to clarify just what sort of death the infant will die, namely, the "death" of a century of sleep, to be broken by the kiss of a prince.

The story of Isaac's blessing of Jacob and Esau strikes us, at first reading, as belonging more to the realm of fairy tales than of inspired Scripture. The force of the story is rooted in the expectation that the patriarch Isaac has but one blessing to give, a blessing he means to give to his elder son Esau but which, through the cunning of his wife Rebecca, it his her son, Jacob, who fools Isaac and receives the coveted words from his father's mouth: God give thee of the dew of heaven and of the fatness of the earth, abundance of corn and wine. And let peoples serve thee and tribes worship thee: be thou lord of thy brethren, and let thy mother's children bow down before thee. Cursed be he that curseth thee, and let him that blesseth thee be filled with blessings. When Esau returns and both he and Isaac discover the trick that has been played upon both of them, none of Esau's entreaties can undo the word of the patriarch. What he has said must, like the words of the wicked fairy, come to pass: Thy brother came deceitfully, and got thy blessing. Even after a tearful appeal by Esau, the most Isaac can provide is a lesser blessing that still remains: In the fat of the earth and in the dew of heaven above shall thy blessing be. Nothing can altogether unsay what has been said.

This resemblance between the two stories is not, I think, a reason to reject the latter because it echoes the wisdom contained in the former. What the story of Esau and Jacob reminds us is that God does not do anything twice. When God offers us a new beginning, and most especially when he calls us to a new possibility of life in the Lord Jesus Christ, he does not do so simply by annulling what has happened. When God has offered us life in one way, and we have chosen to pass it by, the fact that we have an inexhaustible store of mercy, grace, and blessing in Jesus Christ does not means that the same terms, the same mercies, the same blessings and grace will come again our way. This is not because Jesus Christ is somehow petulant or stingy with the life and love he offers us. Rather, it is precisely because he takes our choices, and all of the events of the world he has made, including even the interventions of those agents of wickedness in our lives, the wicked fairies that plot our undoing, into account and grants them their due.

All the same, what the fairy tale recalls in a remote way and the story of Isaac's sons recalls in a shadowy and prophetic way, is nonetheless still true in the blood of Jesus Christ, namely, that there is always another blessing awaiting us. The blood of Jesus Christ is, for us, a reminder of the unending source of blessings, ever living and ever new, flowing from the side of the Savior. That we will need to face the consequences of our own and others' refusals of grace is part of living in a world broken by sin, but that the love of Jesus Christ always offers for us another way, a deeper and more profound way, to be conformed to his divine life, is just as certain. If we have been struck with a curse to die, by the power of the Cross, this need not be the end of us. In the merciful blessings of our God, even death itself has become for us the way to be awoken to new life by our Bridegroom and prince, our Lord Jesus Christ.

Friday, March 9, 2012

Friday of the Second Week in Lent

Genesis 37:6-22 / Matthew 21:33-46

And Ruben hearing this, endeavored to deliver him out of their hands, and said: Do not take away his life, nor shed his blood ...

Reuben, the eldest of the sons of Israel, presents us with something of a puzzle in the story cycle about Joseph. On the one hand, Reuben appears to collude with the rest of his brothers in plotting to be rid of their younger brother and Israel's favorite, as well as in deceiving their father Israel in claiming that Joseph was slain by beasts, rather than sold in slavery to Ishmaelites. On the other and, Reuben, we are told, did not truly wish any harm to come to Joseph, convincing his brothers to cast Joseph into a well rather than kill him outright. He said this, we are told, being desirous to deliver him out of their hands, and to restore him to his father. Even so, when the Ishmaelites come, Reuben does not prevent Joseph's being sold into slavery, and he does not confess to his father the wrong they have done to their brothers. This turns out in fact to fulfill divine providence, to save not only Egypt from famine, but Israel as well, and so set up the circumstances for the Exodus, the giving of the Law, and the forging of Israel as a people to occupy and possess the Land of Promise. Yet, Reuben knew none of this.

It is of course true that all of God's plans will come to pass, that nothing happens save that God in some sense will it to be. All the same, this does not permit us to sit by idly while wickedness occurs before our eyes. Even if we may be less wicked, less culpable than those who demand innocent blood, our best intentions cannot erase our silence when standing up for the weak and defenseless actually costs us something. For Reuben to have defended Joseph would have been a risk, a risk that he, too, would face the murderous envy of this brothers. It may indeed have been right to seek to save his brother in a way leading to minimal risk to his own person. However, when it became clear that the choice was his brother's enslavement and possible permanent exile from his home and Reuben's own facing up to his brothers to defends Joseph, Reuben chose to abandon his brother to an unknown, and to the best of his reckoning, terrible fate.

In those countries where there is little daily risk in professing the Christian faith, we can easily find ourselves in the place of Reuben. For the sake of clever strategy, we might defend the innocent and helpless in ways that require a minimal cost from ourselves, and that may well be right. Even so, are we ready to confess our faith in Christ when there may well be a terrible price to pay? Do we compromise with those of murderous intent, who seek the blood of the child in the womb or the criminal on death row, to maintain our place at their table? Or, knowing the fate of Joseph, do we throw ourselves upon the providence of God, and rather than just presuming all will be well while we play it safe, endeavor instead to speak the truth boldly even when our life seems forfeit, confidence in the knowledge that, through our Lord Jesus Christ, there is no wickedness on earth that has not already been overcome by the glorious and life-giving power of the Cross?

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Thursday of the Second Week in Lent

Jeremiah 17:5-10 / Luke 16:19-31

There are two ways for one's name to last through the ages. The one way is to have done something notable for the good of others. In an obvious way this fate falls to the name of men and women of political prominence whose rule was decisive, long, or both. In this light, we have come to remember not merely the names, say, of Queens Elizabeth and Victoria, but have even names who eras, styles, and attitudes after them. Others have made such a profound gift to culture in their artistry or in the profundity of their thought that people across the world cannot fail to have heard of them: Homer, Plato, Confucius, Dante, Shakespeare, Bach, Mozart, and others as well. On the other hand, some names are recalled not because of their positive contributions, but in light of their villainy, its extent, its depth, or in some terrible cases, for both of these. So, we cannot mention Jezebel, Brutus, Judas Isacriot, Caligula, Gilles de Rais, Adolf Hitler, without summoning up notions of what is dark and perverse in the human heart, however far removed we may be from their actual wickedness.

Jesus' account to the Pharisees of Lazarus and the rich man upsets these expectations we have of the memory of names. While often called a parable, this story is remarkable in actually naming one of the figures, Lazarus. While parables are, by their nature, not about anyone in particular, and thus potentially about anyone in the audience, this story recalls and preserves for ever the name of a man so ignored in his own life on earth that no one did give him even the crumbs that fell from the rich man's table, and moreover the dogs came and licked his sores. Overlooked and insignificant in worldly terms, the whole Christian world now knows this man's name, Lazarus, and will remember is for all eternity.

The rich man, a man of substance and certain influence, a man who might well have been respected by his peers and contemporaries, is left forever without a name. Even as other features find themselves inverted — his comfort and Lazarus' misery exchanged for his torment in the flame and Lazarus' dwelling in the bosom of Abraham — so in the fate of their names as well. Lazarus, the unknown beggar, is now known across the world and for all time, the rich man will be, like rejected kings of the ancient world or like disgraced officials in Stalin's Soviet Union, struck out from the historical record, never again to have their name spoken, their images and names removed from all public monuments.

To be sure, in the past this rich man was graces with the name Dives, taking the word used in the Latin Bible for "rich man" (dives) and, in a kind of desire for symmetry with Lazarus, the named beggar, giving this character also a name by which to be remembered. While there might be some kindness in sympathizing with the rich man, humanizing him by giving him a name, the desire to do so betrays two mistakes about his fate. The first is that, for those who have turned decisively from goodness and charity, who by the hardness of their heart simply fail to see the misery of those about them and the clear and unambiguous teaching of Moses and the prophets, the abolition of their name is a kind of mercy. Whoever this man was, his name is at least preserved from becoming a sign of wickedness for us.

More than that, in naming the rich man Dives, we distance ourselves from his sin, and do so at our own risk. To the extent that we can think this is simply a story about a very particular man named Dives, a man who has died and already been judged, we need not see quite so immediately what the story has to do with us. Indeed, we might be prone to think that the only audience needing to hear this story was the original one, namely, the Pharisees to whom Jesus presented his account. On the other hand, when we remove the comforting name, can be be altogether sure that those nameless beggars whom we have bypassed in our own lives have not been named Lazarus? Can we be quite certain that we are not, even now, but moments away from the torment of the flame, when we have not merely Moses and the prophets, but Jesus Christ himself? Can we, who have just precisely the witness of Jesus Christ, one who has risen again from the dead, afford to think that the story of Lazarus is about anyone other than ourselves?

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

St Thomas Aquinas, Confessor and Doctor of the Church

Wisdom 7:7-14 / Matthew 5:13-19

In the dialogue TheƦtetus, Plato has the figure of Socrates relate to his interlocutor TheƦtetus a story about Thales, who may well have been the first philosopher. Socrates tells that Thales, so intent on looking at the sky, tumbled into a well. This led to the mockery of a servant girl, who noted that he was so intent on the things of heaven that he did not know what was going on around his own two feet. Socrates agrees, in some sense, with this portrayal of the philosopher, who in his search for wisdom is nonetheless unable to make his bed and cook a meal. Yet, for Socrates, what marks the philosopher off from other men is the fact that he, as opposed to the rest, is concerned with what is in fact productive of human happiness: contemplation of wisdom, the very life of the gods. While the rest of the world goes about busily from this to that, the philosopher's life is one of holy leisure, free by his pursuit either to move from topic to topic as seems right or to return again and again to the same question, even as people immersed in the world are tied to the clock, forced to move on to what the schedule of earthly affairs demands of them, and so never able to rise above what ultimately proves to be the misery of a life bound to the world. In this way, even Socrates' accusers who are calling him to trial for the corruption of youth are far less happy than Socrates, who will die by their judgment.

Quite a different vision of the pursuit of wisdom is found placed by the Scriptures into the mouth of Solomon, and by the Church on this feast into the mouth of Thomas Aquinas. Solomon states that he asked for wisdom, preferred her to all kingdoms and riches, beyond all earthly goods, and received not only wisdom, but all good things together with her, and innumerable riches through her hands. While he rejoiced in them all, at first he did not see, but would later come to realize, that these other riches were not gratuitous extras, rewards for having sought wisdom above all. Rather, they came precisely because he had wisdom, precisely because those who are wise become the friends of God. The Solomonic wise man, unlike the Greek philosopher, does not find himself silly before a foolish world, the butt of servants' jokes. Instead, his wisdom, not in spite of being directed to heaven, but because of it, gives him a better and truer estimation of how to live here and now, how to make best use of the riches of this world.

While some stories of the Angelic Doctor might suggest in Thomas a kind of Thalian simplicity and silliness, Thomas Aquinas is surely more Solomonic in his wisdom. Indeed, such was his view of the gift of wisdom that it provided not only for our speculative goals, but for our practical ones as well. Wisdom, for Thomas, is seeing things in light of the highest causes, indeed in light of the highest cause, God himself. More precisely, Thomas asserts that to be truly wise, to have not only the natural habit of wisdom but the gift of the Holy Spirit bearing the same name, is the result of love. It is from the love we receive from God, and in turn our kindled love for him, that we come to see him, ourselves, and the world, not in partial, broken, finite, and thus untrue ways, but the way God himself sees, and thus as they truly are. This is because, through love, we come to see things as our lover sees them, to want what our lover wants, to reject what our lover rejects. Thomas, who devoted his life to study, and had only the highest of praise for cultivating the life of the mind, nonetheless valued even more highly the intuitive and all the more probing wisdom of those who are holy, of those who even without formal study all the same know things aright, those who have become friends of God.

Our Lent can feel as though it has made us like Thales, pursuing what is right to the mockery of a misunderstanding and deluded world. Yet, our feast today assures us that the wisdom our Lenten practice affords us is of a Solomonic sort. Lenten fasts and observance do not direct us to the heavens at the expense of negotiating the things of the world. Rather, as Thomas reminds us, they are to kindle in us love, and openness to the love poured out on us by Jesus Christ through the sending of his Spirit into our hearts to dwell with us as Friend and Advocate. Love is our motive force in Lent, and Love is our guide. It is Love that will see us through to the end, and in that divine Love, we will know all things, in heaven, on earth, and under the earth, not out of our own craft, but through having been made like to the very mind and heart of God.

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Tuesday of the Second Week in Lent

3 Kings 17:8-16 / Matthew 23:1-12

One of the most difficult aspects of repentance is holding to two important truths at once. The one is having and unfailingly honest and unsanitized account of one's own sins. The other is to have an equally robust confidence in divine pardon. Generally, we end up finding our way to the first without taking full account of the second, and we do so to our own spiritual peril. Some people, for example, become so aware of their own sins without appreciating God's mercy that, despite continuing to serve others generously among their neighbors or within their community, they are withering away inside, confident only of their own failures. They become convinced that if anyone knew what they knew about themselves, then they could never lift up their heads again.

Others, however, find themselves unable to bear the weight of awareness of their own sins, and so they project their own grave disappointment in themselves on others. They might start out by lashing out at the Church's teaching that point out their sins, but they slide all too easily into pointing out the moral failures of the Church's own leaders and teachers, hoping thereby to avoid paying attention to their own crimson faults.

Jesus, however, counsels us otherwise: The scribes and Pharisees have sitten on the chair of Moses. All things therefore whatsoever they shall say to you, observe and do; but according to their works do ye not; for they say and do not. Jesus is fully aware of the ways that those who teach us the Gospel and who proclaim it from pulpits in churches across the world have failed, and failed to their own peril, to live up to the Gospel they preach. All the same, this is not and cannot be an excuse for us to avoid attending to the truth of their proclamation. To fail to heed what the authentic teachers of the Gospel proclaim is to plug up one's ears against having and honest, true, and illusionless understanding of oneself. It is also, and this is the graver harm, to fail to hear the proclamation of divine pardon which these same ministers are authorized to announce to every creature.

Taking moral criticism from men with feet of clay can be a bitter pill to swallow if we insist on holding to unrealistic and deceptive stories about our own virtue. What Jesus Christ recalls for us is the royal road to hearing the Gospel worthily and well: the way of humility. It is in humility that we can receive a right sense of who we are and how we have lived our lives. It is humility that empowers us to hear God's voice in the broken and sadly sometimes shrill voice of his disciples. It is humility that will soften our hearts, and in that softening let us believe in the full depth of God's pardon, a pardon not of a false and paper-thin replica of our sins, but even of the worst of our betrayals.

He that is the greatest among you shall be your servant. And whosoever shall exalt himself shall be humbled; and he that shall humble himself shall be exalted.

Monday, March 5, 2012

Monday of the Second Week in Lent

Daniel 9:15-19 / John 8:21-29

And they understood not that He called God His Father.

A not uncommon critique launched by those who disbelieve against the Christian confession that Jesus Christ is God, the Son of God, begotten of the Father before all ages is what they take to be the manifest absence of a clear admission on Jesus' part of this core part of our creed. A typical example is found in John's Gospel. They therefore said to Him: Who are Thou? Jesus said to them: I am the beginning, Who also speak unto you. Now, unbelievers in a generous mood might admit that a believer could, after some unpacking of this claim, and already inclined to see in Jesus Christ, regard this as an admission of his full divinity. Even so, they wonder whether any neutral reader would be remotely inclined to hear his claim this way. Furthermore, since the cost of failing to believe is, by Christ's own admission, quite high — Therefore I said to you that you shall die in your sins: for if you believe not that I am He, you shall die in your sin. — those not of the faith complain that Jesus really ought to have been more direct in his answers, that at least the guilty could not, with some justice, assert that they did not realize that this was what he was saying.

Even so, it is far from clear what kind of admission the unbeliever wants. In the face of the Christian confession of Christ's Sonship, Islam of old and of today quite often retorts that Jesus cannot be a son unless God had a wife, and the idea of God producing offspring sexually is ridiculous. Latter-Day Saints, of course, make just the reverse claim, and take Jesus' admission to be God's Son to mean just that, namely that he is the natural offspring by God the Father from a heavenly Mother. Presented with the claim that he was from all eternity, his own contemporaries quipped that he was not even fifty years old. The pagan world, and the Medieval Jewish world, sneered at the notion that the infinite and holy One should be implicated in the finite and carnal life of the world. It is hard to believe, then, that the problem is a lack of clarity on Jesus' part.

Yet, on this score, we who enjoy the gift of faith cannot afford to be proud. We, who know and believe that Jesus in the Son of God, the beginning, have no excuse not to live as he has told us. However hard his commands may seem to us, however difficult to receive what he says of God his Father or of the life to come and how we can be made fit for the kingdom here and now, we are bound by our own creed to attend to his every word. Many things I have to speak to you and to judge of you ... and the things I have heard from Him, these same I speak in the world. It is all to easy to dodge around our difficulties in living out the Christian life by claiming a faulty transmission: by the evangelists themselves, by the Church, by our catechists, and the like. Either we accept that Jesus is the Son of the Father, and that he rightly and effectively spoke his words not just in a remote way as the beginning, but right here in the world, and that the truth of these words was affirmed in his being lifted up on the Cross, or like the rest in unbelief, we are of this world and will die in our sins.

This is, all the same, Good News. If we are alive in Christ, then we are conformed to him, and if conformed to him, then it is in our suffering for the sake of the Gospel our being lifted up, that we will see that truth he came to reveal about his Father. It also means that, being made like to him, we are also not left alone, and that in the presence of God himself, we too may be confident to do always the things that please Him. In the light of this comfort, we may also say with the Psalmist: Be tHou my Helper and my Deliverer: O Lord, make no delay. Let mine enemies be confounded and ashamed, that seek my soul.